If you opened your Bexar County appraisal notice this year, you might have had a reaction.
But here’s what’s different in 2026…
Most homeowners didn’t receive one at all.
Out of more than 734,000 properties reviewed in Bexar County, only about 196,000 were mailed Notices of Appraised Value. That means the majority of homeowners saw little to no change in their assessed value – or at least not enough to trigger a notice.
And while that might feel like a good thing… it doesn’t automatically mean your value is correct.
In fact, in a market that has shifted from the peak frenzy years, some properties are now being held at values that may no longer reflect what they would realistically sell for today.
So whether your value went up, stayed the same, or even decreased slightly… it’s still worth taking a closer look.
Why Your Appraisal May Not Have Changed (And Why That Still Matters)
The Bexar Appraisal District evaluates your home based on what they believe it would sell for as of January 1st.
In recent years, that often meant noticeable increases as home values climbed rapidly.
But this year looks different.
With the San Antonio market stabilizing – and in some areas softening – many homes didn’t see large enough changes to trigger a new notice. Instead, values were left relatively unchanged or adjusted slightly.
And that’s where some homeowners get caught off guard.
Because a stable value doesn’t necessarily mean an accurate one.
Your Appraisal Is Not Your Tax Bill
This is the first thing to understand: the number on your appraisal notice is not what you owe.
Your appraisal is the assessed value of your property. Your actual tax bill is calculated by applying the tax rates from all the taxing entities that apply to your property – your city, county, school district, and various municipal utility districts or special districts.
So if your appraisal went up by $30,000, your taxes won’t go up by $30,000. They’ll go up by a percentage of that increase, based on the combined tax rates in your area.
For most San Antonio homeowners, the effective tax rate is somewhere around 2.5% to 2.8% of the appraised value, though it varies depending on where you live. If your appraisal increased by $30,000 and your effective rate is 2.5%, your annual tax bill would increase by roughly $750.
That’s still a meaningful increase. But it’s not the full appraisal amount, and understanding the difference helps you evaluate whether protesting is worth your time.
Homestead Exemptions Limit How Much Your Taxes Can Increase
If your home is your primary residence and you have a homestead exemption filed, there’s a cap on how much your taxable value can increase each year.
In Texas, homestead exemptions limit the annual increase in your home’s taxable value to 10%, even if the appraised value goes up more than that. This is called the homestead cap, and it’s one of the most valuable protections homeowners have.
So if your appraised value jumped from $300,000 to $350,000, your taxable value for school district taxes – which make up the largest portion of your bill – can only increase by 10%. That means your taxable value would be capped at $330,000 for school taxes, not $350,000.
This protection only applies if you have a homestead exemption on file. If you bought your home in the past year and haven’t filed for the exemption yet, you need to do that immediately. The deadline to file is April 30th for the year which you are applying.
You can file online through the Bexar Appraisal District website. It takes less than ten minutes, and it can save you hundreds of dollars annually.
The Quiet Risk: When Your Value Stays the Same
A lot of homeowners assume that no notice – or a small change – means everything is fine.
But that’s not always the case.
If your home’s appraised value is being held steady from last year, it may still reflect pricing from a stronger market.
And if the market has softened since then, your value could now be higher than what your home would realistically sell for today.
That’s where overpaying happens – not from dramatic increases, but from values that quietly stay too high.
A simple way to think about it:
If your home wouldn’t sell for that price today… why are you paying taxes on it like it would?
Should You Protest Your Appraisal?
n 2026, the decision to protest isn’t just about large increases.
It’s about accuracy.
Even if your value didn’t change – or only changed slightly – it may still be worth reviewing if it reflects current market conditions.
Sometimes the appraisal is accurate, and protesting won’t change the outcome. Other times, the appraisal is inflated, and a well-supported protest can reduce your taxable value.
Here’s how to evaluate whether protesting makes sense for your situation.
Protest if your appraisal seems high compared to similar homes in your neighborhood. If comparable homes – similar size, age, condition, and location – are appraised lower than yours, that’s a data point you can use. The appraisal district is supposed to value homes uniformly, so inconsistencies matter.
Protest if your home has condition issues that weren’t accounted for. If your roof needs replacing, your HVAC system is older, or your home has deferred maintenance that affects its market value, the appraisal may not reflect that. You can submit evidence of these issues as part of your protest.
Protest if your appraisal exceeds recent comparable sales. If homes similar to yours in your neighborhood sold for less than your appraised value, that’s strong evidence your appraisal is too high. Comparable sales are one of the most persuasive arguments in a protest.
Don’t protest just because your appraisal went up. If the increase reflects actual market conditions and your appraisal is in line with comparable properties, protesting is unlikely to result in a reduction. The appraisal district isn’t required to keep your value flat if the market moved.
Not Sure Where Your Home Stands?
If you’re trying to figure out whether your property value is accurate, I can help.
I’m offering a quick, no-pressure review using real sales data in your neighborhood so you can decide if a protest makes sense.
How to Protest Your Appraisal
If you decide to protest, the process is straightforward, though it requires some preparation.
The deadline to file a protest is May 15th, or 30 days after your appraisal notice was mailed – whichever is later. Most homeowners will be working with the May 15th deadline.
You can file your protest online through the Bexar Appraisal District’s website. You’ll need your property account number, which is listed on your appraisal notice.
When you file, you’ll be asked to provide evidence supporting your claim that the appraisal is too high. The strongest evidence includes:
Recent comparable sales in your neighborhood – homes similar to yours in size, age, and condition that sold for less than your appraised value.
Photos or documentation of condition issues – anything that affects your home’s market value but may not have been visible to the appraisal district.
Your own appraisal or market analysis – if you had your home appraised recently for refinancing or another purpose, that appraisal can serve as supporting evidence.
Once you file, you’ll receive a settlement offer from the Bexar Appraisal District. This is their proposed reduction based on your initial evidence. You can either accept the settlement or reject it and proceed to a hearing.
If you accept the settlement, the process is complete and your appraised value is adjusted accordingly.
If you reject the settlement, you’ll be scheduled for a hearing with the Appraisal Review Board (ARB). The hearing can be conducted in person, by phone, or through written submission. You’ll present your evidence, and the panel will make a final decision on your appraised value. Once the panel decides, that value is final – you don’t have another opportunity to accept or reject it.
If you don’t feel equipped to handle the protest yourself, you can hire a property tax consultant to represent you. Most consultants work on a contingency basis – they only get paid if they successfully reduce your appraisal, and their fee is typically a percentage of your tax savings.
What Happens If You Don’t Protest
If you don’t protest, your appraisal stands, and your tax bill will be calculated based on that appraised value.
That’s not necessarily a problem. If your appraisal is accurate and reflects market conditions, there’s no reason to protest. You’ll pay taxes based on your home’s actual value, which is what the system is designed to do.
But if your appraisal is inflated and you don’t protest, you’ll be overpaying on your property taxes – not just this year, but potentially for years to come. Appraisals build on each other, so an inflated value this year becomes the baseline for future increases.
That’s why it’s worth taking the time to evaluate whether your appraisal is fair, even if you’re not sure you want to go through the protest process.
A Note for Military Homeowners
If you’re active duty military and you own a home in San Antonio, you may qualify for additional property tax relief under Texas law.
Military personnel who are deployed or stationed outside Texas can qualify for a homestead exemption even if they’re not currently living in the home, as long as they intend to return. You can also defer property tax payments while on active duty in a combat zone.
These protections exist, but they’re not automatic. You need to file the appropriate forms with the appraisal district and provide documentation of your military status.
If you’re unsure whether you qualify, contact the Bexar Appraisal District or speak with someone familiar with military property tax issues. These exemptions can make a significant difference in your annual tax bill.
Plan Ahead for Next Year
Property taxes are part of homeownership in Texas, and they’re not going away. But there are ways to make the process less stressful.
If your taxes increased significantly this year, start planning now for how you’ll handle next year’s appraisal. Set aside extra funds in your escrow account if your taxes are escrowed, or start building a buffer in your budget if you pay taxes directly.
Review your appraisal notice as soon as it arrives each April. Don’t wait until the protest deadline is a week away to evaluate your options.
And if you’re considering selling your home in the next few years, keep in mind that rising appraisals can affect your resale positioning. Buyers will see your property taxes when they review the listing, and high taxes can be a deterrent – especially if comparable homes in nearby neighborhoods have lower tax bills.
This isn’t a reason to panic. It’s just a reason to stay informed.
The Bottom Line
This year’s property tax cycle looks different than the last few.
For many homeowners, values didn’t spike – they stayed the same or even declined slightly.
But that doesn’t automatically mean they’re right.
Whether you received a notice or not, the smartest move is to verify your home’s value against what’s actually happening in today’s market.
If your appraisal is accurate, you can move forward confidently.
If it’s not, you have the opportunity to correct it before the May 15 deadline – and potentially save money not just this year, but in the years ahead.
If you’re not sure how your home’s value compares to recent sales, I can help.
I regularly pull local comps for homeowners to give them a clearer picture of where their property stands in today’s market – especially when they’re deciding whether to protest.
Jennifer Anderson is a San Antonio Realtor providing local market insights with a focus on far west side neighborhoods and the needs of military and relocating families. She helps clients interpret market data in practical terms so they can make confident buying and selling decisions.
Social Cookies
Social Cookies are used to enable you to share pages and content you find interesting throughout the website through third-party social networking or other websites (including, potentially for advertising purposes related to social networking).